You've got the investigation report. What happens next?
Once an investigation report lands on your desk, the facts have been found, but nothing has been decided yet. Your next job as the employer is to consider the findings, tell the employee what you're thinking, hear their response, and only then make a decision. The report is the end of the investigation. It's the start of your decision.
Why doesn't the investigator decide the outcome?
Because in New Zealand those are two separate roles. The investigator finds the facts: what happened, and whether each allegation is substantiated. The employer, or someone they appoint as the decision-maker, decides what to do about it.
Keeping these apart protects the fairness of the process. When I write a findings report, I set out what I found and the evidence behind it. I don't recommend a warning or a dismissal. That's your call, and it should be made with fresh eyes.
Step 1: Read the findings carefully
Go through each allegation and its finding. Check that you understand:
which allegations were found to be true, partly true or not true
what evidence each finding is based on
anything the investigator couldn't establish, and why
If something is unclear, ask the investigator to explain it. Don't ask them to change their findings.
In all cases, once you've read the final report, talk to your HR team or lawyer before moving to the next step.
Step 2: Decide whether there's a disciplinary issue
If none of the allegations were substantiated, the process may be over. Let the employee know in writing and think about what support everyone needs to move on.
If some allegations were substantiated, ask yourself how serious the behaviour is. Is it misconduct, or could it be serious misconduct [link to Post 2 once live]? Your employment agreement and policies will guide you, but the decision has to be fair and reasonable in the circumstances.
Step 3: Give the employee your preliminary view
Before you decide anything, meet with the employee. Share the findings and the outcome you're considering, and give them a real chance to respond. They can bring a support person or representative.
This step matters. Skipping it, or making it a box-ticking exercise, is one of the most common reasons a decision is later found to be unjustified.
Step 4: Consider their response, then decide
Listen to what the employee says about the findings and the proposed outcome. They might raise something you hadn't considered, such as their length of service, past record, or personal circumstances. Weigh it properly, then make your decision and confirm it in writing.
Step 5: Close the loop with the person who complained
The person who raised the concern needs to know the process has finished. You usually can't share the details of any disciplinary outcome, but you can tell them the investigation is complete, whether their concerns were upheld, and what you're doing to stop it happening again.
Step 6: Look at the bigger picture
A report often reveals more than the allegations themselves. It might show gaps in training, unclear policies, or a team culture that needs attention. Think about what changes would prevent the next complaint. A clear complaints process is a good place to start.
Frequently asked questions
-
No. Even with clear findings, you need to give the employee a chance to comment on the outcome you're proposing before you decide.
-
You can, but you'll need good reasons, based on the evidence. If you think the investigation missed something, talk to the investigator rather than quietly reaching a different conclusion.
-
They should see the findings and the evidence relied on, so they can respond. How much of the full report you share depends on your process and on protecting witnesses' privacy.
Karapiti provides independent workplace investigations and clear findings reports for NZ employers. Talk to Steve on 021 121 9831.